What would voter turnout look like if, in the 2027 presidential election, the final choice came down to Jean-Luc Mélenchon versus Marine Le Pen? To mark the fifth anniversary of the weekly magazine Franc-Tireur, Ifop assessed this scenario by measuring, for the first time, the voter turnout in the second round of the presidential election based on the most likely matchups—Jean-Luc Mélenchon versus Marine Le Pen, Édouard Philippe versus Marine Le Pen, Raphaël Glucksmann versus Marine Le Pen…—as well as the factors influencing potential abstention in theevent of a matchup between populist candidates.
The results reveal that a matchup against Jean-Luc Mélenchon would generate the lowest voter turnout. Behind this record-high abstention rate lies the portrait of an orphaned electorate—ranging from the moderate left to the moderate right—that refuses to choose “between two extremes” and for whom the “Republican front” reflex, still alive and well when facing the RN alone, ceases to function when the alternative, too, bears the label of “extreme.”
KEY FIGURES
1. A first round expected to draw a strong turnout
👉 68% of registered voters are expected to cast ballots in the first round on April 18, 2027, according to our estimate conducted six months before the election. This figure is the same as at the same point in time before the 2017 presidential election (68%) and significantly higher than before the 2022 election (59%).
👉 75% of French people say they are interested in the 2026 presidential campaign, compared to 67% at the same time in 2021 and 71% in 2016. In 2017, these levels of engagement ultimately led to an 80% turnout in the first round.
2. A showdown between “extremes” that would demobilize voters more than any other scenario
👉 38% of registered voters would abstain in the event of a runoff between Jean-Luc Mélenchon and Marine Le Pen: this is the highest rate among the three hypothetical matchups against Marine Le Pen, ahead of the scenarios involving Glucksmann – Le Pen (36%) and Philippe – Le Pen (35%) scenarios.
👉 That amounts to only 62% of voters , far below the final turnout figures observed in previous presidential runoffs (never below 72% since 2002).
3. A Disoriented Center and Moderate Right-Wing Electorate
Proportion of abstainers in a Mélenchon–Le Pen matchup, based on first-round voting:
👉 65% of Édouard Philippe ’s first-round voters would abstain.
👉 42% of Raphaël Glucksmann ’s voters would also abstain.
👉 58% of French voters who identify ideologically as centrists would not participate in this runoff.
4. The Republican Front Faces the Test of the “Two Extremes”
Reasons cited by those who plan to abstain from a Mélenchon–Le Pen runoff as decisive:
👉 63% do not want to vote for “an extreme candidate”—a refusal that, this time, targets both finalists and not just the National Rally (RN).
👉 61% believe that no candidate defends or represents their ideas, compared to 55% of abstainers in the 2022 second round (+6 points).
👉 42% see no difference between the two candidates’ platforms, compared to just 27% in 2022 (+15 points), between Emmanuel Macron and Marine Le Pen.
🗣️ Direct Quotes “Democracy cannot be held hostage by the far left or the far right.” (Male, 59, voted for Édouard Philippe in the first round) — “Between the brown plague and cholera, I’m not voting.” (Male, 67)
THE AUTHORS’ PERSPECTIVE:
While caution is warranted when analyzing a second round before the first has even taken place, this study has the merit of sketching, for the first time, the contours of a two-faced electorate. Mobilized and proactive in the first round, where they expect the election to bring about change; resigned—or even absent—in the second round, once the choice is narrowed to the two poles that part of the country views as equally undesirable. In between, it is not interest in politics that is collapsing, but the political spectrum’s ability to represent those who—from the moderate left to the moderate right—do not identify with either of the two finalists. This has consequences for the legitimacy of the elected official: a president elected with a large majority of the votes cast, yet receiving fewer votes than the number of those who abstained, would constitute an unprecedented situation in the history of the Fifth Republic.
TO CITE THIS STUDY, YOU MUST USE AT LEAST THE FOLLOWING WORDING:
“An Ifop study for Franc-Tireur conducted via a self-administered online questionnaire from November 2 to 4, 2026, among a sample of 1,834 people registered on the voter rolls, drawn from a sample of 1,978 people representative of the French population aged 18 and older.”
Click on
to make Ifop your preferred source!